Cobblestones, jacarandas, and the loudest bells in the Americas. The editors’ note placed it here on the basis of three criteria: durability across re-reads (or re-watches, or re-plays), influence on the entries that came after it, and the degree to which it could only have been made by the person — or team — who made it.

In the comparative table maintained by the Places desk, The Vault Keeper sits within a band of 7 – 13 that contains some of the most contested swaps of the year. Editors vote with arguments; a swap requires three editors and one written defense.

Also in City

#003

Pale Garden